Vučić defeated in Serbia: A system of national control collapses

By Biagio Carrano

Last night, around 9:00 pm, something almost surreal occurred in Belgrade.

The massive contingent of law enforcement officers, riot squads, and armoured vehicles that had been deployed across the streets of the Serbian capital’s city centre since the morning vanished within minutes. At the capital’s ‘London’ junction, the hundred or so hopeful young people who had already gathered watched as police officers first lowered their visor guards and shields, then opened the barricades, smiled at the youths, and shook their hands, before simply disappearing altogether. Around 9:20 pm, police and special forces vanished from the Presidential Palace, the access roads to the electoral commission, Pionir Park – which had been turned into an encampment for young Vučić supporters and dubbed Ćaciland – as well as from Terazije and Slavija. A few eerie minutes of emptiness and silence followed.

At 9:30 pm came the news so many had hoped for, but so few truly believed in.

The peaceful celebrations could begin.

Not a single poll or statistical model had predicted such an overwhelming victory for the Students’ list. The BIRODI poll went so far as to attribute 48.5% to the students – not the final 52% – and had been considered unreliable. In the model we published on Thursday in the Serbian Monitor, a majority of seats for the Students was estimated at a 10% probability, corresponding to 138 seats rather than the 141 they eventually secured.

It is, therefore, a sensational result. This is not only because it demonstrates how old polling methods have turned into tools of political propaganda (the last Ipsos poll published on Thursday 22 October at 9:00 pm gave Vučić a 47.5% lead), but because it clearly shows that reality, mobilisation, and the privacy of citizens who do not publicly express their true intentions ultimately still prevail over any predictive model – even those based on artificial intelligence.

The surge in support for the students became dramatic over the last two weeks. The public first grew to believe a majority could be reached in Belgrade and Novi Sad, then came to feel that so many people had come forward that others could take a stand without fear. This brought about a silent majority that felt swept up in the momentum. Polling, statistical models, and the intuition of political analysts (including the writer of this piece) completely failed to grasp this widespread feeling, or at least its true scale.

This was not simply down to a winning campaign strategy in the last fortnight. On the contrary, over two years of activism, the Students succeeded in boosting voter turnout by 10 percentage points, rising from 58% in 2023 to 68% yesterday. It was a door-to-door, village-by-village effort – the only way to challenge Vučić’s political machine. That machine had recently received a boost following the change of ownership at Adria News Network (N1, Nova S, Nova.rs, Danas, Radar) – the only media group that had offered sympathetic coverage to the opposition against Vučić. The group was sold by the private equity firm BC Partners, the majority shareholder of United Group, against the opposition of minority shareholder Dragan Šolak (who has initiated legal action), to the Portuguese fund Alpac Capital, led by Pedro Vargas David. Vargas is closely tied to Viktor Orbán’s circle through his role in 4iG and Hungarian funds, whilst his father, Mário David, served as a long-time advisor to Orbán. At the last check, Luxembourg had not yet approved the transaction.

A generational revolt

This is also a generational revolt. Anyone who took to the streets yesterday evening in any Serbian town or city saw almost exclusively teenagers and young adults. The political apathy of which young people are so often accused usually stems from a single factor: they are rarely offered a cause or principles in which to believe and invest themselves. When that happens, as it did in Serbia – on a simple yet clear political platform to oust a regime as corrupt as it was, overbearing and often incompetent – young people not only mobilise, but also demonstrate extraordinary generosity. For two years, facing an unimaginable scarcity of resources (far removed from any talk of foreign funding), often refraining from buying clothes or going out, young people across the country self-funded thousands of campaign and awareness initiatives. Here too, a stark contrast emerged: while one part of the country flaunted its financial success through designer clothes and luxury bags – often tied to proximity to the regime – the students dressed simply like students anywhere else in the world.

Not merely a defeat, but the collapse of a control network

When you suffer a defeat of this magnitude after effectively controlling every lever of power for over a decade – from the police to the judiciary, from the banking and economic system to civil service and its most peripheral branches; when media and publishing outlets have been stifled, often by withholding advertising or jobs from those who refused to toe the line – the takeaway is that this is no ordinary political setback. It marks the end of an entire political and historical era. This was not a standard election; it was a referendum for or against Vučić. The result was as decisive as it was stunning: not just a defeat, but a clear demand for his complete departure from political life.

Now, the Serbian Progressive Party (SNS) might technically retain the ability to form an opposition and attempt to undermine the new political direction, thanks to the sprawling presence of tens of thousands of its members within state institutions and administration. Yet another outcome is entirely plausible: that Vučić’s personal party, faced with the prospect of sitting in opposition despite having been built solely to exercise power, simply dissolves. This could happen for three main reasons: the opportunity for certain party figures to leave the country to escape imminent judicial investigations; the loss of the financial resources that sustained the work of thousands of members at local and national levels; and a typical streak of conformity that will lead many activists to avoid raising their heads against the new establishment.

A new era is opening for the country for another reason as well. The Socialist Party is no longer in Parliament. For the last 25 years, it acted either as the kingmaker in Democratic Party-led governments or as a subservient junior partner to Vučić, content so long as it retained its slice of power.

In this sense, one could argue that the country’s transition is complete. However, this is true in a very specific way: not that the country now has a clear, fixed direction, but that in a single night it chose to rid itself of both Vučić and Dačić – two of Milošević’s key associates from the 1990s. To be sure, a faction within the Students’ list considers Ratko Mladić a hero, but that may carry little weight in practice. The fact that political figures who have dominated the scene for over thirty years are now excluded from power is a monumental shift; that a segment of the population remains nostalgic and nationalist is something seen in almost every country in the world.

As usual, the European Union was nowhere to be seen – or, as political expediency dictates, a few of its representatives only surfaced this morning after the dust had settled.

The cult of stability – or rather, inertia chosen as a survival strategy – led most EU member states and European institutions to avoid taking any clear stance. On the one hand, the chaotic and politically contradictory nature of the Students’ list made it difficult to classify along traditional left-right lines. On the other hand, Vučić was viewed as a necessary evil, the classic embodiment of “there is no alternative” – the phrase typical of those who simply resist change or fear it too much. The political model of the SNS relied heavily on a game of ambiguity, perhaps mutually convenient, played with the European Union.

However, there is an essential political reality to consider. The EU’s hesitation also stems from the fact that a majority of the newly elected representatives on the Students’ list are either anti-EU or deeply disillusioned with it. At best, they will ask: “Where were you when we were being beaten with truncheons, or when our university colleagues and we were humiliated, lost our jobs, or had our funding cut?” If previous dialogue was ambiguous, future discussions promise to be no less challenging.

The revenge of the intellectual class

For the first time in Serbia’s history, the academic and intellectual community holds a political majority. This is a remarkable outcome in a country that, since the 1990s, systematically degraded academia while Željko Mitrović’s television channels promoted superficiality, reality stars, and the so-called Estrada which promoted silicone implants and quick money over education and intellectual pursuit. In the new parliamentary majority, 48% of elected representatives will be university lecturers, secondary school teachers, or primary school educators. This segment of society has spent decades feeling demeaned both socially and materially. A tenured university professor in Serbia earns €1,150 net per month; a researcher or associate professor earns just around €1,000; and secondary school teachers earn even less. These figures highlight how urgent it will be, regardless of individual political leanings within the new majority, to direct funding into education, research, and healthcare.

When speaking of the intellectual community, one cannot overlook the Serbian diaspora. Tens of thousands of Serbs worldwide – many of whom remained abroad to work after completing their studies – queued for hours outside Serbian consulates to vote. This collective mobilisation reconnected the homeland with diaspora Serbs, who are frequently accused of being out of touch or disconnected from the daily struggles of those living in the country.

Who will be the new Prime Minister?

This brings us to the single biggest political challenge. Having claimed to have no leaders and to base their decisions on an assembly-style model, the Students’ list must now delegate a significant portion of its grassroots, horizontal authority – the very key to its success – to a single individual. In-fighting over potential candidates has already begun among the newly elected MPs. In reality, the only candidate capable of reassuring both international institutions and the movement’s own base may not be an elected member of parliament at all.

An economist with the prestige and theoretical expertise to lead a government capable of tackling the inequalities exacerbated by years of uneven economic growth is Branko Milanović, one of the world’s leading scholars on income inequality. Born in Belgrade to a family of diplomats, he spent over twenty years at the World Bank as lead economist in its research department after earning his PhD. Today, he teaches at the CUNY Graduate Center in New York and is affiliated with the Luxembourg Income Study. He became widely known for the “elephant curve”, which illustrates the winners and losers of globalisation (the big winners being the emerging Asian middle class and the global elite; relative losers being the lower-middle classes in rich nations). Crucially, he has maintained strong ties to Serbia, frequently engaging with the country’s liberal-democratic circles on his return visits.

A figure like Branko Milanović could reassure the liberal and left-leaning wing of the students’ list – which remains a minority – while ensuring that regional inequalities between urban areas and the countryside (a sensitive issue for the patriotic wing of the student movement) receive proper attention.

Furthermore, there is the immediate challenge of passing the 2027 state budget, where funding for (or justified by) Expo 2027 represents a major expenditure item. It is highly likely that the event will be scaled back, with funds redirected towards education and healthcare. Foreign investors will need reassurance that they can operate in the country without requiring political connections, while foreign businesses and managers will look for stability against monetary volatility and wage inflation. Economic prospects for the third and fourth quarters are less promising than the first six months suggested, as public spending was deliberately front-loaded to boost GDP growth figures ahead of the campaign. The inevitable slowdown in growth driven by construction – often pursued with little regard for environmental impact or infrastructure capacity – must be quickly offset by a model centered on businesses capable of producing value added recognised in international markets.

This is why appointing an economist as Prime Minister is far more than a theoretical possibility. It is not merely a matter of changing a political system, but of thoroughly reforming an economic and public spending model whose imbalances triggered the dramatic events of last night.


I

Share this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

scroll to top