Independent media in Serbia: A cry for help

The increasingly authoritarian Serbian government has steadily broken down press freedom over the past four years.

Some 150 Serbian news outlets and advocacy groups organized a collective blackout last month to draw attention to the dire state of media freedom in the country, replacing websites with nearly blank screens and the statement, “This is what it looks like when there is no free press.”

While it did not mention him by name, the protest was clearly aimed at President Aleksandar Vučić, who since coming to power as prime minister in 2014 has sought to squeeze critical media out of the market and discredit the few journalists with the funds and fortitude to keep working.

ournalists have made a habit of embarrassing his government. Among other recent accomplishments, they—along with protesters—have forced Vučić to admit that Belgrade officials were responsible for covert, illegal demolitions in the city’s Savamala district; spotlighted Interior Minister Nebojša Stefanović’s failure to stop the destruction; exposed the fact that a state anticorruption drive’s highly publicized criminal allegations rarely result in convictions; and scrutinized the mysterious origins of €200,000 with which Defense Minister Aleksandar Vulin bought his home. (Vulin’s widely mocked explanation was that he borrowed the money from a generous in-law in Canada, and was not required to declare it to customs authorities because he brought it over in installments of less than €10,000.)

This work is all the more remarkable given the Vučić government’s prolonged campaign of harassment against independent media, which has helped to drive down Serbia’s score in the annual Freedom of the Press index. In the most recent edition, which covered events in 2016, Serbia posted one of the largest single-year declines among all of the 199 countries and territories assessed.

Serbian journalists have been lauded this year by prominent international organizations, but at home they face arbitrary tax investigations, choked-off advertising revenue, and outright intimidation, including personal smears splashed across the pages of government-allied newspapers.

The price of independence

One recent tax investigation targeted the local newspaper Vranjske novine, which was highly regarded for its reporting on corruption and organized crime, after it published an interview with the director of the local tax authority. The probe was categorized as “urgent” by authorities and lasted weeks, but never produced charges of wrongdoing. According to editor in chief Vukašin Obradović, it nevertheless contributed to the paper’s closure.

A similar case against Adria Media Group, one of the largest publishing companies in Serbia, played out over the summer. After the group’s Kurirtabloid carried sharp criticism of Vučić, its bank accounts were frozen by tax officials in June and again in July.

Meanwhile, media firms that are more friendly toward the government receive generous rewards. According to the Center for Investigative Journalism of Serbia (CINS), Pink International Company, the media conglomerate that operates the vociferously pro-Vučić broadcaster TV Pink, was granted more than €7 million in public loans between June 2014 and January 2016, despite being named in 2014 as one of the largest tax debtors in the country.

A 2016 report for the Center for International Media Assistance (CIMA) highlighted the case of the local television station Lastavica, owned by Bratislav Gašić, the intelligence chief whose vulgar harassment of a woman journalist once sparked a protest movement. The station’s license was revoked after it failed to pay certain fees, but it continued broadcasting without interference, and over €100,000 in fees and associated fines against it were eventually dropped.

Moreover, private companies are wary of advertising with independent outlets. The daily Danas suffered a rapid cancelation of advertising contracts after it failed to support Vučić’s candidacy in the 2017 presidential election. For their part, many pro-government media carried front-page advertisements, purchased by the ruling Serbian Progressive Party (SNS), that promoted Vučić’s bid.

Journalists who criticize the government are typically tarred as traitors, social degenerates, and tools of the mafia or foreign intelligence agencies. In the wake of the recent exposé by the award-winning Crime and Corruption Reporting Network (KRIK) on Vulin’s questionable home purchase, KRIK editor in chief Stevan Dojčinović was called a drug addict in a statement by Vulin’s political party, the Movement of Socialists. The document added that “Dojčinović was paid from abroad for every article that attacks Vulin” and that “anyone who loves Serbia and who fights for it, Dojčinović hates immensely.”

Additional threats to media freedom in Serbia include the stacking of public broadcasters with government loyalists; defamation lawsuits; threats and other extralegal intimidation, particularly against women journalists; and physical attacks for which perpetrators enjoy impunity.

Periodic admonishments from the EU, the OSCE, and international advocacy organizations have failed to prevent the alarming deterioration of Serbia’s media sector. If they are to protect the small cadre of independent journalists working to hold Vučić’s government to account, these groups will have to sharpen their denunciations of flagrant violations, such as menacing smears and bogus financial inspections, and call attention to less visible factors like market manipulation and politically compromised regulators.

They must also step up financial support for independent media, ensuring that high-quality investigative journalism remains a viable alternative to cynical government narratives. Vučić and his allies seem to understand that unfettered reporting could help to consolidate democracy, strengthen independent institutions, and expose networks of corruption. The question is whether the international community understands this too.

By Shannon O’Toole

(Freedom House, 05.10.2017)

https://freedomhouse.org/blog/cry-help-serbia-s-independent-media

 

This post is also available in: Italiano

Share this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

scroll to top